Plastic vs metal dog food containers

Short answer: plastic bins are lighter, cheaper and often come with airtight claims and wheels. Metal cans resist chewing — Behrens calls its galvanized can rodent proof — and Hill's says clean metal is acceptable. Either way, the bag inside the container is what Hill's and the FDA recommend.

Plastic (HDPE, PP)Stainless can with inner bucketGalvanized steel
Examples hereVittles Vault, IRIS, Van Ness, Buddeez, OXOsimplehuman Medium, X-LargeBehrens 10 gal
Airtight claimVittles Vault, IRIS, OXO yes; Van Ness noyes (silicone gasket)not claimed
Rodent claimnonenone"rodent proof" (Behrens)
Odor and oilsoils absorb into plastic over time — wash regularly (Vittles Vault); plastic may impart odor and taste (Hill's)food touches the plastic bucket, which lifts out to washclean metal acceptable (Hill's); dry storage only (Behrens)
WheelsVan Ness yes; Vittles Vault, IRIS 15 qt, OXO norear wheelsno

Hill's: plastic containers may impart odor and taste to food; clean metal containers are acceptable; keep the food in its bag inside the container (Hill's Pet Nutrition). FDA: whatever you use should be clean, dry and have a snug lid (FDA).

Decision tree

  1. Mice or rats where you store it? Yes → galvanized steel (Behrens), kept somewhere dry.
  2. No → Ants or humidity? Yes → a container whose maker claims airtight (airtight list).
  3. No → Want it to look at home in a kitchen? Stainless (simplehuman); otherwise plastic is lighter and usually cheaper.

Pest specifics are in keeping ants and mice out; a stainless can against a plastic vault in simplehuman vs Vittles Vault; cleaning by material in how to clean the container.

Specs verified: November 2026 · Updated 2026-11-18 · How we research