As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.
Short answer: the simplehuman X-Large is a kitchen piece — stainless outside, a plastic inner bucket, a lock-tight handle, a magnetic scoop, rear wheels and a 10-year warranty — for 36–44 lb. The Vittles Vault Outback 50 is a plain 50 lb HDPE vault with a screw-on lid, no wheels and (in this variant) no scoop, but more stated capacity and a lower tier.
Spec
simplehuman Pet Food Can, X-Large (CW1889)
Vittles Vault Outback 50 lb
Stated capacity
36–44 lb lb (we use 36)
50 lb
Volume
35 L
not published
Outer size
18.1 x 10.4 x 27.4 in (retailer)
14 x 14 x 20 in
Lid type and access
lid clamped by a lock-tight handle; scoop: magnetic, mounted under the lid
Material trade-offs are in plastic vs metal. The simplehuman Medium (25–29 lb) is on the metal page. Size check: a 40 lb bag needs about 49–65 quarts loose — use the size calculator. The other 50 lb bins are on the 40–50 lb page.
The two containers
Premium
simplehuman Pet Food Can, X-Large (CW1889)
36–44 lb lb (we use 36) stated
35 L
lid clamped by a lock-tight handle
Good fit for: 40 lb bags in a kitchen (36–44 lb range); slim 10.4 in width beside a cabinet; rear wheels and a magnetic scoop.
Variant
Brushed stainless, CW1889
Stated capacity
36–44 lb lb (we use 36)
Volume
35 L
Outer size (L x W x H)
18.1 x 10.4 x 27.4 in (retailer) The maker doesn't print dimensions as text; figures from a retailer listing.
Lid type and access
lid clamped by a lock-tight handle; scoop: magnetic, mounted under the lid
Limits: removable plastic inner bucket inside the steel can; 36 lb is the bottom of its range, so dense 40 lb kibble fits more easily than airy kibble; dimensions from a retailer listing.
Skip it if… you buy 50 lb bags; you want the whole bag inside.
Good fit for: 50 lb bags poured in; covered outdoor or garage storage (maker: indoor or covered outdoor; climate-controlled recommended); a screw lid with double gaskets.
Variant
Granite Stone, 50 lb, without scoop
Stated capacity
50 lb
Volume
not published
Outer size (L x W x H)
14 x 14 x 20 in
Lid type and access
screw-on lid
Seal
threaded lid with double gaskets (Gamma Seal)
Airtight claim
yes (maker)
Material
HDPE plastic, food-grade complies with FDA food-contact rules (maker)
Wheels
no
Stackable
not published
Bag goes inside (maker)
not stated
Dishwasher safe
not published
Warranty
not published
Made in
USA
Limits: no wheels — a full 50 lb bin is carried by its molded handles; this variant comes without a scoop; wash and dry regularly; oils absorb into plastic (maker).
From the maker:
Wash and dry the container regularly: over time oils absorb into the plastic and can make food rancid. (Vittles Vault care instructions)
Skip it if… you need to roll it; you want a lid that flips open with one hand.